Blog · 2026-05-15
What "organic" does not mean
The USDA seal is a rulebook about how food is grown and handled, not a promise that nothing was sprayed or that the food is better for you.
Ingredients, labels, delivery and the supply side of food that says what it is.
Blog · 2026-05-15
The USDA seal is a rulebook about how food is grown and handled, not a promise that nothing was sprayed or that the food is better for you.
The garden center was packed the Saturday before Mother’s Day. I was there for basil and two pepper plants, and I wandered into an aisle under a green banner that read Organic Gardening.
The shelves were lined with sprays. Copper fungicide. Neem oil. Insecticidal soap. Sulfur dust. Most carried a small seal saying they were approved for organic use.
I picked up the copper fungicide and turned it over. Instructions to wear gloves and eye protection. An EPA registration number. And in capital letters: KEEP OUT OF REACH OF CHILDREN.
The word organic, in other words, was printed on a pesticide.
That bottle corrected something I had believed for years. I thought organic meant no pesticides. It does not.
The USDA organic standard is a set of rules about what a farmer may use. Most synthetic pesticides and fertilizers are off the table. Growers are expected to prevent problems first, with crop rotation, resistant varieties and beneficial insects. When that is not enough, they can reach for an approved list that includes copper, sulfur, plant oils, certain bacteria and a short roster of permitted synthetics.
Those sprays are not automatically gentle. Copper can build up in soil, which is why the rules restrict how it is used. What separates an organic farm from a conventional one is the list, not the sprayer.
It does not mean more nutritious. Comparisons of organic and conventional produce have not turned up big, consistent differences in vitamins or minerals.
It does not mean local or small. An organic apple can come from an enormous orchard or from the other side of the world.
It does not make processed food healthy. Organic cane sugar is still sugar, and organic cookies are still cookies.
It does not always cover every ingredient. “Organic” on a package means at least 95 percent organic ingredients, not counting water and salt. “Made with organic” means at least 70 percent, and those products cannot carry the USDA seal.
And a missing seal does not mean the farm sprays. Growers selling $5,000 or less in organic products a year are exempt from certification, and some larger growers follow the same practices without ever applying.
The seal does guarantee real things: no synthetic fertilizers, no sewage sludge, no irradiation, no genetic engineering, and a yearly inspection by a certifier the USDA accredits. For animals, it means organic feed, no antibiotics or added hormones, and access to the outdoors. That is a meaningful standard. It is just not the one most of us picture.
I went home with the basil, the peppers and no fungicide. The next time someone calls a vegetable chemical-free because it is organic, I will think about that bottle.